Skip to main content

How Schools Fail: Lost Kids and a "Race to Nowhere"

Something is rotten in our education systems - on either side of the pond. 87 percent of all young people in the US want to go on to college after high school and yet one in three drop out of school. Reasons include the need to earn money, early pregnancy, having to care for a relative, and in some cases academic challenges that seem insurmountable; 69 percent of drop outs state that they are "not motivated or inspired to work hard". Drop out rates are highest among blacks, Hispanics, and Native Americans, where one in two children do not finish high school. (Data from this PBS Newshour report and from The Silent Epidemic - Perspectives of High School Dropouts, a report prepared for the Bill and Melinda Gates foundation in 2006.)

At the other end of the spectrum are those who are pushed to give their all, usually white or Asian kids. A recent documentary about this group of students, Race to Nowhere, talks about the pressure these children face and often cannot hold up to. It shows how these students are driven to achieve top grades in their middle school years so they may get into the best high schools from where, if they work hard, they might move on to one of the top colleges which might land them a well paid job and - according to some people - will make them happy.

Since high schools and colleges favor well rounded applicants students add a host of extracurricular activities to their schedule: sports, music lessons, drama classes, community service, Scouting. In many cases the pressure gets too much and leads to symptoms of burn out: headaches, inexplicable stomach pains, eating disorders, depression, and sometimes even suicide.

The movie got me thinking about one of the differences between the US and the neck of Europe I come from. The distinction is even touched on in Race to Nowhere's subtitle, The Dark Side of America's Achievement Culture. America is a fast paced, competitive society. Those who work harder are promised a bigger slice of the cake, at least on the levels of money and prestige. Whether the promises always come true or not - in the US the race is always on. Like in any race there are many who get left behind, either because they don't have the energy, motivation, or monetary means to keep up or because they overexert themselves early on and wear out before the finish line.

Austria is different. To begin with it has a dual education system. At the age of 14 those who do not want to go to college later can start on a path where they will receive educational schooling alongside vocational training or an apprenticeship. It is the route nurses, hair stylists, mechanics, bakers, and other professionals take. Those who do finish high school basically all get the same chances: colleges in Austria are public and free; right now there are only one or two fields where universities cannot accommodate all applicants; a degree from one Austrian university carries as much prestige as a degree from another, so why race?

I long for the middle ground, a place where - to begin with - happiness does not have to be synonymous with more money and prestige; a place where (like in Austria) students who would drop out of school if the path is too narrow are not lost and where (like in the US) those who want to enter the race for a well paid job get a better chance if they work harder than others. Hard to find, I'm sure.

Comments

debi said…
Christina,

I love your new cover picture.

I agree with your last paragraph. I like the middle ground, also. Fortunately, my kids found that middle ground through vocational type schools. They're not 100% happy 100% of the time, but they're content with their choice of careers, and they have no school debt.

I believe that parents make the largest impression in the child's life choices. I've seen friends of my kids that were pressured to achieve so much that they suffer the symptoms you listed - that's unfair to the child. I've also seen the opposite - parents that don't care - they won't spend the energy. Raising kids (if you do it right) is the hardest thing you will ever do.

There's plenty to be improved in the education system, but in my opinion the American family needs to be the first priority of change. But, how do we make that happen? other than taking care of our own.

Excellent post,
debi
Debi,

Thank you for your kind words and for staying with Across the Pond through three weeks of silence. The picture shows a slice of La Jolla beach in San Diego. I took it years ago.

I agree with you that change ideally starts in the family, but I worry for kids whose parents don't get the message and are simply not up to the task. Is it fair that these children should be left behind?
Lorraine Seal said…
It's been my impression that in Europe student who are not aiming for a university education in general get more well-rounded and comprehensive education than their US counterparts. In part, I'd guess, it has to do with the national curriculum and testing in secondary schools. Unless a student is planning to take the ACT or SAT, US students don't face a universal test in order to leave school.

My husband completed his secondary education in Ireland a little over 30 years ago. He didn't go on to a university, but his level of knowledge seemed comparable with those in the US who had completed the first two years of college-level education in the US. It seemed the secondary education was more rigorous and taken more seriously than in the US. Here in Austria my neighbour is an English and French teacher in a secondary school. Not all of her students are university-bound, but their English language skills are impressive. I doubt you'd find that level of instruction for non-university bound students in the US.

Popular posts from this blog

Visions of Editors: How Good Stories Go to Waste

Recently I stumbled upon Visions of Mary, a war story by Joseph Richardson. The book begins in a present day emergency room in Tennessee: A physician, a good guy who takes his work seriously, fights to establish the identity of a man who was found wandering about in a snow storm. The M.D.'s questions bring up memories of World War II in the disoriented patient. Thanks to the lost man's recollections we eventually learn that he is Colonel John Stone, an American war hero. The colonel tells the physician how he enlisted and became a pilot, how he married his sweetheart, Mary, and how he almost died when the Japanese shot down his plane, the "China Doll," in the last months of the war. After the attack, Stone and his men found themselves on a raft in the middle of a shark infested nowhere called the Pacific. Without food, water and radio connection their death seemed imminent. The men's fight for survival is where the book turns exciting: plunged into this crisis,

Lyman, Whitford, Reality Check: A Career in the West Wing?

On a chilly Sunday night in February two young girls in jeans and light blouses were standing in front of the artists' entrance of one of two local art theaters in Pasadena, California. The pathway beyond the barrier, an iron gate, was barely lit. It stayed empty for a long time while the girls, shifting weight from one foot to the other, chatted and giggled. After a while a figure emerged from the shadows. The girls fell silent but it was the wrong actor. When the right man, Bradley Whitford, finally appeared he was wearing a bicycle helmet pushed way up on his forehead. Whitford is best known for playing Josh Lyman in the TV series  The West Wing   but on that night he had performed in the Pasadena Playhouse's production of Yasmina Reza’s   Art.  The girls stopped the actor, told him about their social studies class and how the teacher would have them watch The West Wing.  Whitford smiled, asked, "Which school is it?" and autographed the two print-outs the girls

Solid Rock, Human Transience (The Huntington 2)

Organic blend: Chinese garden at the Huntington The Chinese garden at The Huntington Library, Art Collections and Botanical Gardens in San Marino (L.A. county) is a magical place. It blends the man-made and the natural, architecture with trees, straight lines and curves, all in an organic way. Last week, as I was wandering the cobbled paths of the garden I decided to take a closer look at some of the rocks. I got to my knees, admired the shades of white and grey, the undertones of purple, green, and red; I let my hand glide over the limestone's spurs, cracks, and sharp edges, felt the coolness of the rock against my skin, its enduring solidity against my human transience - and decided to look up some facts. Spurs and cracks: 50 Chinese stone workers flew in to carve the stone Transplants in L.A.: 850 tons of rock The limestone rocks in the Huntington's Chinese garden are transplants. They were imported from Lake Tai in the Yangtze Delta in China. Acc